Julietta Conte, the middle sister in the Conte family, has spent the last few years watching her siblings settle down into happy marriages and burgeoning families while she wondered when her turn would come. As the responsible sister, she learned early that work was not only her salvation but also a way to control the factors around her. Now, devastated after the death of her father, she flings herself into the task of running the family bakery business, La Dolce Famiglia, and inherits control of the Italian empire after her older brother takes off to America to start a new chain.

But as loneliness sets in, Juliette worries that she's destined to spend her life alone. She decides she will give her life to her career, but deep inside, she burns for someone to set her on fire. Her sisters Alexa, Maggie and Carina all believe they met their husbands by completing a love spell, and at her sisters' urging, she reluctantly agrees to cast one herself.