This thoroughly researched, lucid book offers a broad, insightful discussion of a complex subject. Steven Beller is Herzog's immediate scholarly predecessor, yet Herzog goes beyond the excellent work of her predecessors...Her choices of the writings to discuss are thoughtful and sometimes unexpected...Posing challenging questions while keeping the city always in view, Herzog concludes that though this rich tapestry of artists and viewpoints is irreducible, there are similarities and verities to reveal. This is the book's unique contribution. Highly recommended. * Choice
The strength of Vienna is Different lies in its combination of historical contextualization with individual case studies...[It] constitutes an informative guide to the continuities in Austrian Jewish literature during the long twentieth century and will be an excellent handbook for students in the field. * Modern Language Review
This work is on the cutting edge of renewed interest in Jewish Austria. It is a comprehensive road map of a culture uprooted but replanted and blossoming anew into the twenty-first century. This is recommended reading for the scholar of Austrian literary history. * Journal of Austrian Studies
Herzog's book is an excellent study of Viennese Jewish writers-one that not only provides an excellent overview for use in the classroom, but that is also a fine piece of scholarship that reveals how Vienna is different from other European metropolises in the fascinating ways its contemporary Jewish authors reference the city's vibrant literary tradition and cultural legacy. * Austrian History Yearbook
It is worth noting that Herzog gives the reader the necessary historical background to each chapter and sets her writers in their historical contexts. Furthermore, each writer is introduced with a short biographical background on their life and work...In addition to being a well-written and well-constructed book, Herzog's study contributes not only to our understanding of the tradition of the Austrian-Jewish literature but also reminds us some of its forgotten protagonists, among them Felix Salten, the author of Bambi, a work whose fame far outstrips its author's. * European History Quarterly
In tracing a tradition of Jewish writing in Vienna from the fin de siecle to the present, Herzog's book forms an important contribution to our understanding of Austrian literature and culture of the twentieth century. By focusing her analyses on the ways in which these writers conceptualized their identities as Jews, Herzog illuminates the complicated, yet continually changing relationships between Jewish writers and the city of Vienna. * H-Judaic
...meticulously researched and clearly presented...Each chapter begins with a brief, well-informed overview of the period and the experiences of Jews in Austria during that time...This informative work successfully probes the engagement of an impressive range of writers with both their own self-identifications and Vienna. Sensitive and nuanced, it will serve scholars and others as the go-to guide for exploring issues of Jewishness in Austrian literature. * Habsburg, H-Net Reviews
[A]n impressive account of the origins and development of what is now a tradition of Jewish writers in Vienna. The author does a very good job of presenting the very large subject she has taken on and of putting the turn-of-the-century writers within a chronological context that brings out how a 'tradition' of Jewish writers in Vienna has developed over the last century...This is an impressive contribution, with a welcome approach. * Steven Beller, Washington D.C.
[A]n important, extremely well constructed and original inquiry and a major contribution to scholarship on Jewish writing and its authors' literary reactions to the Austrian capital... In a systematic approach and within the proper historical context Herzog uncovers the panorama of Jewish-Austrian writing with Vienna as its focus...Comprehensive and thorough, it conveys a wealth of information on individual authors, their time, and the changing cultural environment. * Dagmar C. G. Lorenz, University of Illinois at Chicago
